Received: from mail2.protonmail.ch (mail2.protonmail.ch [185.70.40.22]) by nld3-dev1.alpinelinux.org (Postfix) with ESMTPS id 410A0781A86 for <~alpine/users@lists.alpinelinux.org>; Mon, 5 Aug 2019 14:40:51 +0000 (UTC) Date: Mon, 05 Aug 2019 14:40:47 +0000 DKIM-Signature: v=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=duniel.no; s=protonmail; t=1565016050; bh=fjgyxCM/oX+ZWQl3q69rrSk/OeFTimwjEv7CPkiKPq8=; h=Date:To:From:Cc:Reply-To:Subject:In-Reply-To:References: Feedback-ID:From; b=BFChjKWkS/vTwEOMHwFBdrRBzPV7+wKd005X8FBz3S6Pbi/IyIpOwOOupuQn79ME6 TtF+A1i7b1G9n+vROeNqWm7zSGnKye6QA4U+ggBgLmVf++tXrPN9p9XiZYfERBzEq2 HZAyspaGYxLznWvvcnmafy51mEdD1eYqav7giXMg= To: "Daniels, Hans-Joachim" From: Daniel Isaksen Cc: "~alpine/users@lists.alpinelinux.org" <~alpine/users@lists.alpinelinux.org> Reply-To: Daniel Isaksen Subject: Re: AW: Trademarks and redistribution Message-ID: =?utf-8?q?=3Cz4Uu6jokR6LRzdmHYNva763zem8SF-25Ojtheckc9gb611c6D1d?= =?utf-8?q?AhPmvEk4ymJUybbBFqsOY9ieusaEXEID5edIpKYmxhl1uqFj0RoLxQDo=3D=40d?= =?utf-8?q?uniel=2Eno=3E?= In-Reply-To: References: <02e1ef466ed14eb59b5e3b46394159c6@emea-msx-1.emea.turck.info> Feedback-ID: =?utf-8?q?M6UsohadiIq4-vYRqoWvKyHDv4Mn9fTsg5lc0N5mVVAl=5FYZi3-t?= =?utf-8?q?ewmHYawfeFjjEIM9MeRHncCndifkvu9Zl9Q=3D=3D=3AExt=3AProtonMail?= MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: multipart/signed; protocol="application/pgp-signature"; micalg="pgp-sha256"; boundary="---------------------b93affd67e0ca0255ce62ec43be91505"; charset="UTF-8" X-Spam-Status: No, score=-1.2 required=7.0 tests=ALL_TRUSTED,DKIM_SIGNED, DKIM_VALID,DKIM_VALID_AU,DKIM_VALID_EF autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no version=3.4.2 X-Spam-Checker-Version: SpamAssassin 3.4.2 (2018-09-13) on mail.protonmail.ch This is an OpenPGP/MIME signed message (RFC 4880 and 3156) -----------------------b93affd67e0ca0255ce62ec43be91505 Content-Type: multipart/mixed;boundary=---------------------d244d54a5cbc2b2a1db57f22080440fc -----------------------d244d54a5cbc2b2a1db57f22080440fc Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable Content-Type: text/plain;charset=utf-8 Hello Hans-Joachim, Alpine Linux has no corporate backer, and does not have any legal entity (i.e. NPO) governing it - it is unlike Ubuntu largely a community effort. If you were to distribute a modified Alpine Linux image, you would most li= kely be including your software rather than altering the actual software, logo,= or copyright notices created by Alpine developers in a malicious way. As for the logo guidelines: https://lists.alpinelinux.org/~alpine/devel/%3= CCA%2BT2pCHpuJcz%3DZs9LkSw%3DJqdrao2kdBfbyTrQsdESKH%3D47tSHw%40mail.gmail.= com%3E Short answer: You are entirely fine using Alpine as the base image for you= r Docker containers. ----- Sincerely / Med vennlig hilsen, Daniel Isaksen (https://duniel.no) =E2=80=90=E2=80=90=E2=80=90=E2=80=90=E2=80=90=E2=80=90=E2=80=90 Original M= essage =E2=80=90=E2=80=90=E2=80=90=E2=80=90=E2=80=90=E2=80=90=E2=80=90 On Monday, August 5, 2019 4:30 PM, Daniels, Hans-Joachim wrote: > Hello, > = > > i can see a part that makes sense but seems may have some ambiguity: > > = > > > > "You can redistribute Ubuntu, but only where there has been no mod= ification to it." > > > > for alpine could be "you can redistribute it and marks as modified= ... to reflect it" > = > What qualifies as "marked as modified"? > Being a Docker images which uses Alpine as a base layer and packs any "m= odification" into another Docker image layer? > = > > also about: > > = > > > Otherwise you must remove and replace the Trademarks and will need t= o recompile the source code to create your own binaries. > > > apine its a trademark ? > = > Your last question left me puzzled. Somehow I can't imagine that the pro= ject name isn't protected. > But if Alpine thinks different than Ubuntu and doesn't want any Icewease= ls running around and is fine with custom images containing the name Alpin= e Linux (which wouldn't have much user visibility anyway since we're think= ing of server Docker images), then this would be an answer for my question= . > = > Where could I find a confirmation on that? > = > Thanks, > Hans-Joachim > = > Turck Electronics GmbH | Gesch=C3=A4ftsf=C3=BChrer, Managing Director: H= ermann Schwagmann, Guido Frohnhaus | Sitz, Registered Office: Detmold | Re= gistergericht, Register Court: Amtsgericht Lemgo HRB 4921 > = > Wichtiger Hinweis: Diese E-Mail enth=C3=A4lt Betriebs- oder Gesch=C3=A4f= tsgeheimnisse, rechtlich gesch=C3=BCtzte oder sonstige vertrauliche Inform= ationen und ist ausschlie=C3=9Flich f=C3=BCr den Empf=C3=A4nger bestimmt. = Sollten Sie diese E-Mail irrt=C3=BCmlich erhalten haben, ist Ihnen eine Ke= nntnisnahme des Inhalts, eine Vervielf=C3=A4ltigung, Weitergabe oder sonst= ige Nutzung des Inhalts der E-Mail ausdr=C3=BCcklich untersagt. Bitte bena= chrichtigen Sie sofort den Absender und vernichten Sie die empfangene E-Ma= il. > = > Important Note: This e-mail may contain trade or business secrets, privi= leged, undisclosed or otherwise confidential information and is only inten= ded for its addresses. If you have received this e-mail in error, you are = hereby notified that any review, copying, distribution or any use of the c= ontent hereof is strictly prohibited. Please inform the sender immediately= and destroy the received e-mail. -----------------------d244d54a5cbc2b2a1db57f22080440fc Content-Type: application/pgp-keys; filename="publickey - d@duniel.no - 0x1E863687.asc"; name="publickey - d@duniel.no - 0x1E863687.asc" Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64 Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="publickey - d@duniel.no - 0x1E863687.asc"; name="publickey - d@duniel.no - 0x1E863687.asc" LS0tLS1CRUdJTiBQR1AgUFVCTElDIEtFWSBCTE9DSy0tLS0tDQpWZXJzaW9uOiBPcGVuUEdQLmpz IHY0LjUuMQ0KQ29tbWVudDogaHR0cHM6Ly9vcGVucGdwanMub3JnDQoNCnhzRk5CRm5UZ05RQkVB Q3NCaHpwT0RlcSthMzVzTlRRS0Y5ck1yem1lZFcwZ29vRzRnOG1RKzl2L1Nqag0KS1pIRG5IM2xz bjJsQnBZRWlQREJYeGlGNXJHMXZUaGlTZmplaklMc1dHOGhxQ2hFQndjd3preDRxKzlODQpheFBO VHhjQlh1YnhiMmNUL2VodWJpdG5ZbEREcTNtSjBiSTl6SWRFL0RLckJ4NTlYc28xOEtOYkFDSjkN CkF5UTV2d2RkaFEzcGxaWVBKY2hjdEdqRFN4VFZJaWxFQStZdjR0cHVDN1BXcm56K1pCdklBMjVV dzJUZA0KMnB0a2pqMXZ2NWFsMHI1VUx3Z3ZrbkQ1eE1JN1pEQnRwTUJqbGF0Vnk2cDMrbXA0MTVC NGZjV3RRNXYrDQpYNC9Wa2tuZWtwTGREWGJjYkI0ZVBqODUzUkptL2l6bFRXRGljMkk2Q3Vib2pB T2pIMVdtbllvNGE4WFINCmVYOHk0SVoyRk1GN05LZkJmcnJjd3c2MGwvRFVZMlYzV21IVUdWRkQ4 Ly90TjZkbmxSdlM4RlBxeXNTUQ0KYXZxK0VCNnlQWnNCN21sOXJERGpDRGFibkxqMFowZGdSMzhY cTA0eENGbktXNlJqMUdWa1hlWEkvKzJYDQpzRXk3Yi9JOFFEQVkzMHVwUWs4WjFiNjZ1NXM1eWxl QVl3alNiRkY3NHVpQS9FZXVjSlBva3lEd2JQWVgNCmRzSzdQUUJreFdqS283cG9zTHd2T2hRM0Fr WWlQTWs1Mm9iK0dYVWhPK1JzNkpIZS9qaU11ZTBqa2llNA0KMjVtY3p2aUoza2pHK1N5c0dMUjVJ TklHTW15RHVsd3JZbitGRUo0NGV1Rm1EU0kyUGwrQXFvYVR0eVRPDQpkUUpCZTZzOUFIT2JqZjN5 QVBVSWdOUjBGYTVKUy9YUFFGbXBZUUFSQVFBQnpSc2laRUJrZFc1cFpXd3UNCmJtOGlJRHhrUUdS MWJtbGxiQzV1Yno3Q3dYOEVFQUVJQUNrRkFsdjRnUlFHQ3drSENBTUNDUkJ5WEJ4Tg0KZ2Y0NWhB UVZDQW9DQXhZQ0FRSVpBUUliQXdJZUFRQUtDUkJ5WEJ4TmdmNDVoQjUrRC8wYUVuSktaUitlDQpN TmptaXZlRkl0MmhSYTd4T0U0cVZicDVPeEh6MEVldGpqditkUzhLVzVDZFY4amNUdERMby9RTEti clINCnlPMWdDYW1MdkpOYTVNRHpPRU1uWjN3TUhUREFibGdJa2ducStOV1ZSNXk4V2FBbGF5NjI4 d2dtbU4wRQ0KeUYwbEJkNW05UDFYOXNwMWxKdjFaMTRCOXI5VHBZKyttbUpwUFlYMWcrOTRvSHZz Q3h0RmdrVm56NndvDQorcUpKcjl0YlBqWGIrWDg3TDVZU0x5U05GWk5JeDZlTi8zYXpoVStFNUFi RFBpWDhTNWVLNUk1T2xSU0QNCkc5bFlVQ1phZjVkTlhGS29ZQVVrL3BFVmFrVHV1MTVpUVh0WStX THl2MU0yMmJrcmJScWV2dXh4ZWVnMw0KRlBTNkliZHZNL21meVhJWmsrNWZEeU9IMXlXSHBZSjJ1 QjJSYTZ1QW1hWkgyL1hNVUMvT1RaeTNxU2M5DQp1K0RSeFJRcVVzb2FpaVRaampaQkhqRUtXU3Q1 V0QzbSt0NnUxS2ROVzVObjRvZnplekxDZ2Z1WVdWNWsNCmtWd3JCdmI2d1VkWTNqQlN6SlNaa3Vr NHpqMFFEb2dMRUVXeFNPbDh6VzhhdFVOdlJDd29HRjNrS3JCcQ0KNXJkcnFXaVNLRENRMFBudDl2 TWZ4UXpjQWFSbmhkQmxZNUROaTBJQU52SHVQL3pTV0JOL0ZaWko4N1VnDQpzWThKY1hSc3ZuZUY0 MEFLc0VMS2p3ZG5SMml4RlQ0U2lXTTZHdHRjTXpNZHVuajdkTC84MkVBdytqMTYNCnZVZnM0M2hI QVpmMFVhVHdUcXdQWVd3cEN3YmM1MXNmM1pUbUp2cTdrWURDaytPT3JqdHczS3BqTURyaw0KSWNO VTRpaXJmZWdLRmM3QlRRUlowNERVQVJBQTBBQ2dFY0M2MzBMblVocDRLTFk0ZU1qSms1dENwYUhF DQphU1AySXpvS05pTkJrY0RyZm1Qdmd2TGNySmg2blBwU29PTjRvUGNTU1VHZDN4U21HZDFkMy8w Z3VpNXoNCkVQR21KMzdXak5wbjdLTXphT05kUGIxdzNEbDJLd21McjN2czhKYTZzMXg4SldKY0Zp STh6WjY1RzBLSg0KemVkRGRRYkN1bmhhOHIyaXVmcHUyQWdSNGFCTFFCSlFmWVFCeTF4QXhnWHJn cjRUYm5oTXQ5TTdTQ3VTDQoyeTYyYnRGdHE4VW0yNVBnQzIwUlpzeHRRMC9TREtTUU93S3JlUEZN NlBpamJFUlJlUDVUZnVSU0RpWGkNCmlMMWFCbHQvTkhxRUxWc2VVZmlkcnBiT0E1M1VUNEZ5YWg4 REFaUUpwTjkwQ293Qm9id0dTRTMrRGJweA0KdWhLVzhSMUcwOWU0T2FMV244eHJIemZaY3ZMUlls VzM4QllLMWxscjFHUG5DQUcrUndGWXQ3ZldzY0xhDQpDQ3doNnFRSEd6ZTFoMlNMYjMyTjViYnRx VE1qR0d2N25leXRvbHltQVZSVEsyRlM5VEdTeXQ5dXdFZFMNCjB4eGpQMEx6bHZVY2dHTlAxMEI0 Zndkb3Q2M1RNUVR0VlBiWlpRViswTnlkMEtMWUEzaUR0amxQc1RjeA0KbzVaWG9DOVBEVVlyS0c1 NTd2ZzFCNVptb1Y0VWREMEFKcmxCTFYxZUxYeDgyb3o3YXJwOE5aWG9vMzN3DQpGelRmQ1kwbUho akU5MnQ2SUdERkFWbjlZRDl2cjByMlBSeGs2WjBMR1orU0NNbTgzQnFMVFh0WnUrNGkNCk16WnZY UlVuSlFZWFh5dTYydkpMVTc2SkFpMWE1d2hCdjExWFNiVzNTYWZFa3hRMmFHMEFFUUVBQWNMQg0K YVFRWUFRZ0FFd1VDVy9pQkZna1FjbHdjVFlIK09ZUUNHd3dBQ2drUWNsd2NUWUgrT1lUVXpBLytP M0oxDQp2RElOUTErZmd3MkhyazJWeGxSU3RDd240Z2YwSXJ2bHM3bmVVVjhEbFpqQW5LQWIzajdI MjRveTI4SHgNCitrQVNmTHhQeGJLcnRWendReTJGOXlDYkpPdkMzVU9ySFpLNzhkUDAxQStmSkh6 L2JkM1llS1NSOSttbA0KZ1BzR3dkNk93MmJiQVRYZC9OMDVIcjVwYVRCa0pha0ZsTUYweTBhUXAy NFl1TXZvcnkvdi8rV1RCYWxuDQpaVFF5T2EzQkR3REt2YnNOREgrSTliWFRPK2NIcUVoR1Bsbk4r NGRtQWxOYVMyTmhUL1lpbzVPSGkxT0cNCmRuQXF5bXVIYk9TdGMrakhxa0dWMW1Pa3lpWHBXV0Qv WTV1aDAxL2FGbHl0SHREYlB5bkhKWDNDZzhBUA0KcmZsa2hzN3JxdVRXVWVpWFdSd1Y1bGEyQlhm UzJtQUxQY1Fyb2lmVUxBZWdrRUNTVWxBZ1J6RFdxVmhSDQpxWER0MWN6NVBPdisyYWx3OFhvT0ho WWpuMEt6NjFiMU5lWXh2NE9JNmhzczcvZ3NLZWV6eVRDNEMxcS8NCkp0VkMvcUJYU0hSSkFFTnYw N0pjeHNHRWVRMGZNQnkvUzhSREdzaGRFcU1zV3Vvd1IybzUyRWVzL2h5Mg0KTmxrdVNXMWQrSGJI cUVoU2FacXBoemhqMlM3Y1JGdW5IcWRxZTdqTGFSRTNDL2s2ZkowdmRSdGQxOWEwDQpnbE8rVWlK UlptakU5cnhReFc4SzRQYU5OWUNXbTF5c0RvWDRmRWdZODNIdytVS09KMEFVa2Y1dkxpSXkNCi9w K0ZGeCtqb0pwRTIrM2w3ekdqek14ZWxkUENJM2FuY1BnT096TCtFUGhyaUZsaVMveHlIYXAxaDZu eA0KaTFQLzAxYm9oKzgyeUxkZXA0QT0NCj1ocTVvDQotLS0tLUVORCBQR1AgUFVCTElDIEtFWSBC TE9DSy0tLS0tDQo= -----------------------d244d54a5cbc2b2a1db57f22080440fc-- -----------------------b93affd67e0ca0255ce62ec43be91505 Content-Type: application/pgp-signature; name="signature.asc" Content-Description: OpenPGP digital signature Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="signature.asc" -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: ProtonMail Comment: https://protonmail.com wsFcBAEBCAAGBQJdSD/nAAoJEHJcHE2B/jmE8f4P/3+dNlR6h6clqc9OBg4P lL8AwAZp3fEO83ZhznckljBE2w6xWhkGUMuYP94KKjjhsODmlXvSFymJ7Aem 4mhnhiWYxpHyF1fpP2Trvwli4CDAIm3S8OskK6kJw+CPNOlCQhAaT9Kx+17A v6QjLN4j+1LChuD3r6tVqajeVjRpF+Y+EKSl0qx37bu5XauZc98ncRIROJ3f pARx9f1keF+tyLwhHAyMdUIQrzdwFGy4NL58Q4RY+F03cbdwn/918ax9LMxc MXGmY5rauK6ET1Au/4oxW89hG/xYzJqoubOoJ4Mjwu+eZiNMqGQI1QfVGccZ cbt1eWzPGT8SqpDzcW2tBhlFD5qP74i/c4PN84jb1YkG14a79DSKAKnggi6J qlYw6jG4E1Sweanhrm4bEabLlla/N4oCuWilxdfw577Pv4ct+c1RGbcnQqOP i4ug8aKlBNDG5XiibC25uz6F5lngraMECl/UW/5wsxBWffQHqBbn9JkWO3Ap nQE0yU/ZjKyWRhnzRCY1jSAgIgp9aO5M7wlYXyuCNhgdDN76OswmMoSyu8D1 /Gq7RnrivMzU5IiEE8L4EaRmg/B25CYC0tiLUdX64x6Kni4OyV2q7EqeyCUl tlsr1zqlD64JmDEudJnc/frzan4XUCKS5x3nF1P3uzNAVQTRNayoYiME496T Vtal =6yCg -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- -----------------------b93affd67e0ca0255ce62ec43be91505--